Weetapidol Pool Results: Final! (AKA: Anti-Shmuel Just Lost Big)

And now, the real results everyone has been waiting for: the results of the somethingth annual Weetapidol Pool!

Let's get our runner-up Jessica out of the way first. She was chosen as the winner by almost everyone, and almost everyone gets 12 points as a result. The outliers are not lying very far out, as Jeremy correctly predicted her at #2, and I put her at #4.

13 points: Jeremy
12 points: Kelly, Wendi, Shmuel, Shari
11 points: Mo

All of this means that nothing much changes in the standings, and that the final results of the pool are determined by Phillip Phillips, he of the awesome name and the touching crying during his coronation song and the half-decent winner's single.

Wendi and Shmuel go into this tied for first place, and it's been neck-and-neck all season long. Wendi didn't make a bad pick, putting Phillip at #4. But Shmuel made an even better pick, and placed Phillip at #2, thus clinching his first ever victory of the Weetapidol Pool! (In fact, he would have won either way.)

13 points: Mo
12 points: Kelly, Shmuel
11 points: Shari
10 points: Jeremy, Wendi

(As you can see, none of us made a bad Phillip pick, but I was never really a contender this season, so I am basking in my successful prediction of Phillip in first place, as well as my victory in Shmuel's pool over at the Idol Annex.)

Overall:

149 points: Shmuel
147 points: Wendi
140 points: Mo
139 points: Shari

130 points: Jeremy
129 points: Kelly


Those of you who have been following along know how momentous this is. Shmuel has participated every time we've had the pool, but not only hasn't won, but hasn't even come remotely close. In fact, one season he did so poorly that we theorized an Anti-Shmuel (someone who ranked the contestants exactly opposite from Shmuel) would do better. To his credit, Shmuel beat Anti-Shmuel every time we tried this.

Anyway. So this is a VERY EXCITING victory that has been a long time coming. Congratulations, Shmuel! And I have the pleasure of offering you the American Idol-related merchandise of your choice! Will it be Haley Reinhart's new CD? A Scotty McCreery commemorative guitar pick? A Taylor Hicks Halloween mask? The choice is yours!

And thanks to everyone for playing this season!

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 3!

And we are down to the top two, with Joshua out in third place. We had Joshua in 9th (Shari), 8th (Jeremy), 7th (Kelly), 6th (Shmuel and Mo), and 5th (Wendi)--and that's the closest we got to third place. So much for the hive mind this time around.

11 points: Wendi
10 points: Shmuel, Mo
9 points: Kelly
8 points: Jeremy
7 points: Shari

Excitingly enough, this one point difference between Wendi and Shmuel puts them in a tie, once again, for first place! OMG EXCITING.*



Overall:

125 points: Wendi, Shmuel
116 points: Shari, Mo
107 points: Jeremy
105 points: Kelly

Next week, almost everyone predicted Jessica to win: Kelly, Wendi, Shmuel, and Shari all picked her! I was the only one who picked Phillip, and thus will look slightly like a genius if he wins. (I think I might also win Shmuel's pool if that happens. Which will help take the sting out of the WGWG fatigue I am feeling.)

Who will win Idol? Will Shmuel FINALLY take win the Weetapidol pool? Find out next week on the thrilling conclusion!

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 4!

Hollie in fourth place! And we are all over the map this week--well, one of us is, anyway.

Shmuel and Wendi maintain their relative standing (with Shmuel one point ahead) by both putting Hollie third, a very strong pick. By contrast, Kelly put Hollie dead last and drops to last place in the overall standings. I had Hollie second and Jeremy had her first. And the bullseye this week goes to Shari, who correctly predicted Hollie to be out in 4th.

13 points: Shari
12 points: Shmuel, Wendi
11 points: Mo
10 points: Jeremy
4 points: Kelly

Overall:

115 points: Shmuel
114 points: Wendi
109 points: Shari
106 points: Mo
99 points: Jeremy
96 points: Kelly

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 5!

So, Skylar is out fifth. I know this was a Shocking Elimination, and I know Shmuel is sad. And that's all I know! Except I know the scores.

Maybe it will take the sting out of Skylar's loss just a little bit if I tell Shmuel that he picked up the perfect score this week? No? How about that it also puts him back in first place? Maybe helps a little? Well, he gets 13 points either way.

Kelly also made a great pick, putting Skylar fourth. Wendi and Shari both had her second, and Jeremy had her third. I guess we all pegged her as a front-runner from the start.

13 points: Shmuel, Mo
12 points:  Kelly
11 points: Shari
10 points: Wendi, Jeremy

Overall:

103 points: Shmuel
102 points: Wendi
96 points: Shari
95 points: Mo
92 points: Kelly
89 points: Jeremy

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 6!

And Elise is out sixth! I actually can't believe we had four girls and two guys; does a girl have a chance to win this season, finally? (Probably not.)

A perfect score this week goes to Kelly! Wendi was only one place off, putting Elise seventh. Shmuel only barely loses a grip on his streak of awesomeness, since he had Elise eighth. I put Elise eleventh, and Shari and Jeremy had her last.

13 points: Kelly
12 points: Wendi
11 points: Shmuel
8 points: Mo
6 points: Shari, Jeremy

This helps Kelly climb out of last place, but hurts Shari, since she was tied with Wendi for first place. Now Wendi pulls away from the pack somewhat. (Only by two points, but still, this season, that's a lot.)

Overall:

92 points: Wendi
90 points: Shmuel
86 points: Shari
92 points: Mo Pie
80 points: Kelly
79 points: Jeremy

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 7

So Colton was out in seventh place last week, which I completely failed to notice. Is anyone still watching this show? Is there anyone good on it? Tell me what performances to YouTube, people.

In the meantime, the results! Wendi and Shari both had Colton sixth, which is almost perfect, and gives them 12 points each. Since they were tied for second place one point behind Shmuel, and since Shmuel put Colton fourth, now they are tied for first, one point ahead of him. DAMN THIS POOL IS EXCITING.

12 points: Shari, Wendi
11 points: Jeremy
10 points: Mo Pie, Shmuel
9 points: Kelly

Overall:

80 points: Shari, Wendi
79 points: Shmuel
74 points: Mo Pie
73 points: Jeremy
67 points: Kelly

Weetapidol Pool Results: Top 8!

And DeAndre is out in 8th place! Pool-wise, the really exciting thing is watching Shmuel hold onto his lead. He squeaks ahead again this week, just barely, having put DeAndre 10th.

Shari was only one place off, putting DeAndre in 7th--landing her one measly point behind Shmuel, who gets first place all to himself again this week. But Shari and Wendi are both close behind, and it's really anyone's game!

(Also, why on earth did I put DeAndre THIRD?!?!)

12 points: Shari
11 points: Shmuel
10 points: Wendi
9 points: Kelly, Jeremy
8 points: Mo Pie

Overall:

69 points: Shmuel
68 points: Shari, Wendi
64 points: Mo Pie
62 points: Jeremy
58 points: Kelly