Tuesday, March 14, 2006

The Official Pool

To enter the Weetapidol pool, list your top 12 contestants in the order you think they will be voted off. Enter in the comments! Weet and Pie will appear in the comments with their entries. Good luck!


Anonymous Merr said...

Kellie, Melissa,Paris,Lisa,Mandisa
Kevin, Ace/Bucky, Taylor, Elliot

8:06 AM  
Anonymous Ana said...

In voting off order...

9:05 AM  
Anonymous Martha from NH said...

Here is my guess, in voting off order:

Kevin Covais
Bucky Covington
Melissa McGhee
Kellie Pickler
Lisa Tucker
Paris Bennett
Ace Young
Elliott Yamin
Taylor Hicks
Chris Daughtry
Katharine McPhee

12:51 PM  
Blogger mo pie said...

Pie's picks:

1. Chris Daughtry
2. Taylor Hicks
3. Kellie Pickler
4. Paris Bennett
5. Mandisa
6. Katharine McPhee
7. Kevin Covais
8. Ace Young
9. Bucky Covington
10. Elliott Yamin
11. Melissa McGhee
12. Lisa Tucker

12:55 PM  
Blogger Weetablog said...

Ok, here's mine, based solely upon this one episode, because I haven't seen any of the others.

12. Kellie
11. Elliot
10. Lisa
9. Melissa
8. Paris
7. Kevin (will last longer than he should because geeks are this year's black)
6. Bucky
5. Taylor
4. Ace
3. Katharine
2. Mandisa
1. Chris

I'm pretty sure that Kellie isn't going to go tonight, as she will get the sympathy vote for having to wear false eyelashes when she hates spiders. Or something. (Read: America is stupid.) But I'm sticking with this.

2:15 PM  
Anonymous Trance said...

OK, I am so happy you guys started this blog I could PEE. Yay. So. I am thinking,

Kevin the Keebler Elf
Melissa who is Dr.Teeth
Bucky who might be cute if he shaved and cut his pretty pretty hair
Kellie who might be too dumb to live
Elliot who looks like a monkey to me for some reason
Ace, and then I will cry, because I want to cover every inch of his body with Nutella and then lick it off
Taylor, because I think people will not be into him, but I think he's fucking rad
Lisa, Pocket Contestant #1
Paris, Pocket Contestant #2
Mandisa, Ms. Supah-Booty who is my fucking idol
Katherine, who is perfect and I hate
Chris, who has a deep sexual relationship with the mic stand.

Not that I've given this thought or anything.

2:40 PM  
Blogger mo pie said...

Hee. Ace covered in Nutella! Thank you for that mental image. Thank you, thank you.

So those are your rankings from last to first?

2:45 PM  
Blogger mo pie said...

Also, Merr, you left Chris off your list! And someone else, because you only have 10 people. Melissa, I think?

2:47 PM  
Anonymous Celine said...

Alright, this may be the most fun idea ever. Here is what I think. In voting off order:
Kevin - because WHY IS HE HERE STILL?
Bucky - He's sweet, but gots to go
Melissa - she's just too hit and miss
Kellie - could she be dumber?
Elliot - having no sex appeal will work against him here
Lisa - now it's getting tough
Ace - I agree with Jen here. HOT.
Paris/Katherine - I am not sure who will go first. And it will make me sad as I like Paris' energy but love K's voice
Taylor - who rocks the party! You dance baby!
Mandisa - who I think will only be in this long as a fluke, I know you guys like her but I don't think her voice stands out enough. And thus, she should go before the beautiful Ace. But she won't, America will vote for her.
Chris - I love him. He is hot and he sings well. Rockers are my kryptonite.

3:39 PM  
Blogger mo pie said...

My parakeets have not yet watched the top twelve, but their official pick for tonight is Elliot, because they hate Elliot.

4:06 PM  
Blogger mo pie said...

Actually, Weet said I should just not tell them who gets voted off tonight. What a good plan!

4:14 PM  
Blogger Shmuel said...

What the heck. Here goes:

1. Chris
2. Mandisa
3. Taylor
4. Kellie
5. Ace
6. Kevin
7. Katharine
8. Paris
9. Bucky
10. Elliott
11. Melissa
12. Lisa

(Yes, this is slightly different from my picks in my own pool this week. I'm hedging my bets and stuff.)

4:48 PM  
Anonymous Bailey said...

is it wrong that I actually thing elliot is very hot? something about his personality. anyway, here's my guess:

1. Kevin - I'm sorry. I did love him, but he's not really good.
2. Melissa - She truly sucked on Stevie Wonder night.
3. Bucky - I love his personality too, and I think he's pretty good, but..I'm not sure he can do so many different styles.
4. Kellie - This dumb act is not going to work for her forever.
5. Elliot - Maybe? I kind of lose it after I get rid of those first four.
6. Lisa
7. Katharine
8. Ace
9. Taylor
10. Chris
11. Mandisa
12. Paris

I'm really unsure of those last four. I don't think Taylor is really..American Idol appropriate, but I do love him. I think Chris, Mandisa or Paris could pull it off.
Did anyone else just think the whole Stevie Wonder show was incredibly awkward?

4:50 PM  
Anonymous Editrix said...

So, I'm cheating because this is after the reveal, but:
Melissa .. buh bye
Kevin ... getting too cocky
Elliott ... too homely
Lisa ... because she's a less-cute version of Paris. Don't need two of them.
Bucky .. sadly, because I like him
Kellie ... uh duh? The dumb blonde act will get you only so far
Ace ... not hot, creepy. Sorry.
Paris ... too perky. Buh bye.
Katherine ... love her voice.
Taylor ... he rocks. I already want his album.
Mandisa ... cause she has the big girl vote
Chris ... Bo was robbed, and Chris is better than Bo.

And Stevie? Time to retire, baby.

10:54 AM  
Blogger mo pie said...

Editrix, no worries, I added you to the spreadsheet. No points for this week, though!

2:47 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home